Ballot for UNSW B vs TCD PHIL B vs TCD PHIL A vs MACQUARIE A Round 3 @ 2306

Motion

This house would redefine the criterion for excessive force in the US to be any use of force beyond what is reasonable given all the facts of the case, including the benefit of hindsight (e.g. whether the individual had a gun, not whether it was reasonable to believe he had a gun).

Scoresheet

  • PM Andrew Manton-Hall 76
  • DPM Kendall Shepherd 76
  • Total for UNSW B (Opening Government) 152
  • LO Harry Higgins 75
  • DLO Harry Morris 75
  • Total for TCD PHIL B (Opening Opposition) 150
  • MG Christopher Costigan 78
  • GW Eoin O'Gorman 78
  • Total for TCD PHIL A (Closing Government) 156
  • MO Georgia Chahoud 79
  • OW Jacob Rock 78
  • Total for MACQUARIE A (Closing Opposition) 157