Ballot for BRANDEIS Z vs CAPE TOWN A vs DUKE A vs BIRMINGHAM A Round 3 @ 4402

Motion

This house would redefine the criterion for excessive force in the US to be any use of force beyond what is reasonable given all the facts of the case, including the benefit of hindsight (e.g. whether the individual had a gun, not whether it was reasonable to believe he had a gun).

Scoresheet

  • PM Kevin Healy 80
  • DPM Ravi Simon 80
  • Total for BRANDEIS Z (Opening Government) 160
  • LO David Harris 79
  • DLO Desmond Fairall 78
  • Total for CAPE TOWN A (Opening Opposition) 157
  • MG Matthew Feng 77
  • GW Salil Mitra 77
  • Total for DUKE A (Closing Government) 154
  • MO Nisha Telesford 74
  • OW Rosalie Butcher 75
  • Total for BIRMINGHAM A (Closing Opposition) 149